to the 2008 Nader supporters
I adore Ralph Nader. I really love him: as a person, as a consumer advocate, as a politician, as a candidate, as a man (and he wasn’t half bad looking in his prime). I supported him all the way in 2004 and put everything I had into that campaign. My car: “The Nadermobile”, the street campaigns from Little Five all the way across suburbia, drafting and printing pamphlets, constant letters to the editors, the perhaps too incensed political column, the vote drive, the campaign debt relief fund.
And in 2004, I was devastated when Republicans ended up taking over every branch of government in addition to Bush winning. But I knew I did with my vote what I wanted to, because Georgia was irreversibly Red and I just wanted to join a campaign in a position that would matter for a candidate I could be passionate about. Things are different now, in a lot of states.
I have always defended Ralph Nader against attacks calling him a “spoiler” or “vote stealer”. I was on board this year: I was signed up to volunteer again, administrating and “director of” his largest Facebook group of supporters, and looking into campaign positions. And that’s when I got this very disappointing email, sent out to all Nader volunteers signed up at that point.
Dated March 3, 2008, from the official campaign website, this email advocated the formation of on campus “Students for Nader” groups that would deliberately pit themselves solely against Obama supporters. Direct quote (emphasis mine, but emphasis only) from the email:
“issue a short, bold, ambitious press statement with quotes from students about why they can’t support the Democrats and why they are supporting Nader. Its also worth sending the press releases to the main corporate media, public radio, etc, however your best chance for coverage is with your campus based paper or radio station.
Organize debates with campus Democrats (or the Obama campaign)
Debates with the Dems are, by far, the best way to get a large student audience. Its MUCH better to only debate the Dems, rather than including the Republicans. If you have to include the Republicans, then focus the discussion on issues that make the Democrats defend their support for their corporate candidates. You don’t want to give them the opportunity to appear as the “sensible center.”
Frame the debate as “Obama or Nader: Who Should Progressives Support?””
Reading that email, I started to question the Nader Campaign’s previous defenses of Nader as not a spoiler or a vote stealer, ones I had passionately argued on their behalf. More importantly, I had to take a serious look at this year and what I wanted to risk. I couldn’t support Nader this year and keep a clear conscience. I relinquished the control of Nader’s Facebook presence. When Nader chose a virtually unknown running mate, doing nothing to strengthen or balance his ticket, that was the final straw. As much as I loathe bipartisan politics, I cared more about doing everything I could within the power of my vote to keep John McCain from being elected. It was more important to put up a fight against a war-hungry man who was handed his candidacy by his Republican competitor, and if elected whose presidency would have very dangerous consequences for all of us.
Grassroots Nader supporters, I identify with you, I appreciate your efforts. I appreciate that your campaign has pushed for dialog about important issues. On November 4th, you can look back on the Nader campaign as time well spent (and perhaps even forward to his next campaign). But on November 5th, could you wake up to a McCain victory and look back on a vote for Nader with confidence that it was the right choice?
I challenge you to carefully reconsider what you do with your vote this year, especially if you are in a swing state. Too much is at stake. North Carolina is up for grabs, and I’m not going to be responsible for handing it to McCain.
I don’t care if you call me a sell out. You can even tell people you’re still voting for Nader, you have the right to voter privacy…no one but you will ever know for sure who you vote for. As long as in the end you do what you know is the right thing—to do everything in your vote’s power to keep John McCain out of the executive branch.
3 years ago • 0 notes